Sunday, September 11, 2016

It's a Boy

I talked to my friend Anna the other night about theories of attraction, but in explaining mine to her, I realized that I was actually talking about just one facet of a much larger problem.


My theory of attraction is that people experience a sort of bodily sense of increased gravity around someone they're attracted to. It's a feeling of being pulled towards them. We may be able to see some patterns emerge in the general types of people we are attracted to, but I don't know that we actually have a lot of choice in the matter. Given things like anti-LGBT priests being caught with male escorts, or government officials who vote against LGBT equality and end up getting caught exposing themselves to other men in public restrooms, I confidently believe that whomever we are truly drawn to, we are drawn to, and that is that.

Knowing that, it's easy to extrapolate that this is the case for not just me, but everyone else. But I must remain especially mindful of including people to whom I am drawn; because they may not be drawn to me. Or perhaps not in the same manner.

I should clarify that this kind of pull does not have to be sexual or romantic.

Returning to Anna as an excellent case in point, I am about 3000% sure that neither of us has a particularly sexual or romantic sort of attraction towards the other. But we do seem to mutually feel a strong platonic attraction, which has created, in me, a sense of being in a sort of sisterly relationship. We enjoy each other's company, and the easy conversation that flows between us. We hardly know each other, really, at this point. But we feel a mutual attraction in this familial and easy way that is often referred to as a "kindred spirit."

Seeing @annabelle__perez off on her last night at #papamurphys with @aldamodeling 😊🙏🏻 #mytransreality

A photo posted by Seranine Elliot (@aggressivefrontpocket) on


I went on to explain that when I experienced a more complete sort of attraction in the past (up to and including the very recent past), I noticed that I would feel a sort of compounding secondary attraction to the idea of being attracted. I was enjoying that feeling, and wanted to hold onto it. In order to do that, I began to paint over the person I was attracted to. They became, from my point of view, a canvas onto which I told my own story about them to myself. In the very beginning of this kind of painting, it is not hard to adjust to things I notice about the way they are that are different from the way I was going to draw them. But before long, they are invisible, hidden by what I want to see in them. The weight of expectation.

I noticed this happening in my mind most recently as I was drawn in a way I have never been drawn before to anyone. I don't mean that in the simple sense of Xtreme Powar Pull or anything. I just mean it is unique in its character, this sense of attraction. I feel powerfully magnetically pulled to her to the extent that I can tell when she enters a space I'm in before I have any way to really know that. I sense that she's arrived, because I feel pulled. I look in that general direction, and see her. I also feel equally powerfully magnetically repulsed, at a fixed distance. It's as if I am a comet who gets pulled into orbit. Exactly this close; hang around; but no closer. It is the most remarkable thing. I treasure it for its uniqueness. But I noticed myself beginning to covet her as its source.

So it was that one day when she did a thing that I found injurious, I found it especially so. Because on some level, I'd permitted myself to believe that she was not capable of injuring me in that way. I had painted over that part of her. I'd made it the realization of a beautiful dream, for me; a woman I'm drawn to in this powerful and mesmerizing way, who is also incapable of hurting me in the most painful ways. But it had nothing at all to do with her. The weight of expectation.

The pain of being hurt was doubled by a tiny sense of betrayal, just large enough to echo the pain back on itself, and double again, and again. But in experiencing that pain mindfully, I saw how empty it was. It was the realization that the movie I was watching wasn't real after all. This angelic creature — for what else would I be drawn to? — was just an actress in a role I'd cast her for, a role I'd been trying to fill without realizing it. She wasn't an angel at all. No flying warrior princess with gleaming armor and a sword that never missed, even when she threw it. No invincible Valkyrie, who would unfailingly be on my side in any fight. But a woman. Not just a woman, or only a woman. A woman. A completely independent person. I would say I am fond of her, but that is a thing I cannot say honestly while setting expectations upon her, for that is not kind. Expectations always weigh something.

I realized that many times in my past, when I'd allowed myself to believe that the women who joined me in failing at being together romantically had really been the ones at fault, I was engaging in this same practice, but not mindfully. I let it play out and run for months, or years. The ones who left me were betrayers. The problem wasn't that I'd misread them, because the attraction was so real. The painting I'd made was so lifelike. The problem had to be them.

But it never was. It never even could have been, because the biggest problem was that I was more interested in being with some idea loosely based on their life than with them. It's possible, perhaps even likely, that they were also doing the same thing with me. But what they were doing doesn't really matter, because what I was doing made every one of those relationships doomed from the start. (Yes, even with #FKAgirlfriend.)

The pain of experiencing all of those kinds of feelings was delightfully brief, this time around. And I am confident it will be one of the last, because most of the pain was the sense of mourning all the time I spent invested in these tools for painting the people I was drawn to out of existence, under a picture of what I decided they had to be.


This most recent and unique attraction still exists, of course. I still feel drawn to her, in exactly the same way I did before. I suppose this is why break-ups hurt so badly. Anyway, she messaged me the other day, telling me about a date she had coming up that night. I felt instinctively a sense of joy. This beautiful creature I was drawn to and intent on observing and protecting in some way, being kind to in some way, was telling me about something that she was excited about. I noticed a sense of joy in myself, a sense of satisfaction that my instinctive response to her telling me this had nothing at all to do with me. I worried that perhaps a few hours or days later, I might feel something else. But so far, I haven't.

By accepting who she is as she is in every moment, and not investing myself into an idea of her that nobody could ever live up to — if nothing else, paintings don't move; people do — I can be as kind as possible to everyone. To her, by seeing her truly, as she is. By demonstrating kindness to that actual person, and not my idea of her. To myself, by not carrying around this painting, and trying desperately to keep it between us, so I can only see something I want, and not someone I can be kind to.

I understand that this is the kindest way to relate to people, now. For myself, anyway. Your mileage may vary. But in understanding that whatever sort of attraction I feel towards anyone is entirely a product of myself, even if I qualify it as a response to them or something about them, I can understand that by extension, everyone else has the same set of conditions to work with, more or less. That is, whether I'm attracted to someone is not up to me; whether someone is attracted to me is not up to them.

What is up to each of us is what we do with that sense of attraction. For myself, I figure if I am going to be inexplicably drawn to someone, I may as well make the kindest possible thing out of that feeling. If nothing else, that keeps things simple; I try to find the kindest action in each moment as it is, already. I have mixed success. But the goal doesn't change, the intention doesn't change, and as long as I don't lose sight of that — as long as being present and being kind are the two foremost practices in my life — I think I shall do much less damage going forward. In fact I think I'll foster some real joy.

In coming to understand these mechanisms through the lens of romance, I realized that the same fundamental principles for attraction can be used to understand the bond between parents and children, because the same kinds of things go wrong for the same kinds of reasons. When children come into our lives, we feel some kind of pull towards them, generally. If we have two or more, we probably feel more pulled towards one, and call them "favorite," to ourselves, and hope nobody else notices. But in any case, it's a pull. It's the pull that we build a bond on, the one that has us doing our best to come home from grocery shopping with the same kids we took there.


I got my birth certificate in the mail the other day. In order to prep for a working retreat over the winter in Mexico, I need to get my passport, and in order to do that, I needed to get a certified copy of my birth certificate. I was born in 1975. I'm not sure what sort of technology they had back then for guessing at my gender. What I am sure of is that until a guess at my gender was made based on what my body looked like, I was freer than I would ever be after that.

The weight of expectation around gender is one of the biggest any of us has. It's even built into the phrasing we have used in birth announcements for at least as long as I've been alive: It's a _____! Without the reveal, we are not even people, really. Not "they," but "it." A thing waiting to have gender conferred upon it. But that is a false construction.

So, I was born, and the doctor said, "It's a boy!" and I screamed for the next 39 years. Mostly internally. Mostly at myself. What I was screaming for was my mother. I wanted her to see me. But she didn't. Because the moment someone told her, "it's a boy!" she started painting.

Being trans is not the only way to get a ticket to this show. In my case, it just put me in a seat with just the right view to see how the magic happened on stage; to see the painters painting. Had my mother been correctly told, "it's a girl!" when I was born, she would still have started painting. Perhaps she would have seen me longer; perhaps the things she felt she ought to paint, the things that said "girl" to her, would have naturally aligned better with what I was actually doing; with who I actually was. But she still would have been painting, and eventually, I would have disappeared.

I understand that teenage rebellion is not rebellion for the sake of rebellion. It is a child saying, I am tired of not being seen. I am tired of being unknown to you. You're so busy staring at your painting of me from when I was born that you haven't had time for me since. Well, you will make time for me. I will make you make time for me. You will see who I am. You will know.

It is rage and hurt at realizing on some level that the people who were supposed to best love us for who we are — the people who we know, deep down inside, were always supposed to teach us how to love ourselves, to teach us that receiving kindness is our birthright, that giving kindness is our duty — taught us that we were only worth covering up. That we were not even worth seeing, never mind acknowledging. Never mind loving.

To disappoint your parents is not a cruelty. It is a kindness. It is freeing them from the weight of the painting they've been holding up between you, the painting that parents start before their children are even born. It is offering them the opportunity to see you. It is giving them the only chance in the world that they will ever have of really putting that painting down. It is giving them the chance to learn how to love someone they have finally just met.

Sunday, July 17, 2016

A Bookmark for Sera

I realized this morning that I've been homeless most of my life.

A few years ago, I was homeless for about a year and a half, in the common definition. I didn't have a fixed address, I couldn't receive mail. I had no landline telephone. For a little while, I had no phone at all, actually. I lived in a tiny, run-down RV in a church parking lot. I hated it there. It was a constant reminder of how badly I'd failed everyone, including my girlfriend at the time, #myfavoritemistake; she lived there, too.

I spent as little time there as possible. Pulling 25-credit quarters at a 4.0 invited questions. People would ask me how I did it. I said, "well, I'm homeless." They'd be shocked and confused, so I'd explain. "When I'm done with classes for the day, I can go back to my beat-up RV in a parking lot in Marysville, with a slanty floor, with cats and trash everywhere, with a girlfriend who can't stand me, or I can be in the library, with level floors, and running water, and climate control, and people who don't touch me because there's room to move around me. You have no idea how awful it is to live on a slanted floor. I can't think there."

I wasn't a naturally stellar student. I was just another girl who was never happy where she was. I had no other way to distract myself from how awful my life was, so I dove into my classes, and I went overboard with it. I spent every waking moment as focused on school as possible, because I couldn't bear to let my awareness rest where I was. I wasn't even planning for the future. I was just taking every class I could, just to take them. Whenever I managed to get a shower, at the school or at the YMCA about a mile down the hill from the RV, I'd run lines in my head, rehearsing French or singing or acting. I never just ate, I ate while doing other things. I was never where I was.

I moved into this house I live in now. It's my friend #GingerAl's place. I hated it, but I hated it less than the parking lot. It was far from everyone and everything, it was also somewhat run-down, it needed work that I had no idea how to even begin to go about doing. There were bugs and spiders everywhere, dust and grime from years gone by. The room I moved into had cut cables dangling from the ceiling in several places, pieces of a broken drum set and other assorted trash. I knew I was supposed to be grateful, that gratitude was all anyone would want to see. I mouthed the words, and tried to pretend I wasn't steeping in bitterness. I used to have a nice place to live. I used to have things.

I moved my computer into the house. I set it back up and patched the games I used to live in: League of Legends, Champions Online, The Lord of the Rings Online. My computer was set up in the living room, because I thought the living room had grounded wiring, and I didn't want to lose my computer while I couldn't afford to replace it. I didn't play my games too much, because there were usually people around, and I didn't want to seem rude. As soon as I realized none of the wiring in the house was grounded, I set my computer up in my room. I returned to my game worlds like a hero coming home. Like a junkie who'd been clean for a year, and then found an old stash. I shut my door, and left.

I tried to clean the place up, sometimes. When some of #GingerAl's friends came over, they remarked that the place looked cleaner than they'd seen it in years. I thought it was still filthy. I mostly gave up trying to get it clean. I started focusing on getting just my room clean. But eventually, I gave up on that, too.

At some point, I realized that I was a girl. It wasn't long before I understood that I always had been. I looked around at the house I lived in, and I felt real gratitude. For a moment. Then, I lost myself in something new: me. I learned how to relax and move without inhibitions. I watched a few youtube tutorials to teach myself how to do my own makeup. I got excited about putting outfits together each day. I looked forward to seeing people. I participated in my classes, I did things.

I thought, "this must be what living is like."

Then, I went home, and I got on the Internet, and I played video games. I could deal with the real world as long as I was doing a thing, like driving somewhere, or working on something, or writing a song... or playing video games. But I couldn't deal with the real world as it was, as I was. And so I'd arrived in the real world, but not really. I was never where I was.

I met a girl on the Internet, which surprised exactly no one, as I'd always met my girls on the Internet. #FKAgirlfriend taught me more about my sexual self than every previous partner had, combined. That's not to say my previous partners were terrible, or even not good — it's that I wasn't there, Before. With #FKAgirlfriend, in sex, I came as close as I ever had to real sustained periods of being present. I didn't know what would come next. I was on high alert, but in pleasure, not terror. I learned what I liked and did not like in bed, and I started learning how to talk with a partner about it all.

Yet even then, I was doing a thing. I was learning sex, and I was present for my own sensations. My girlfriend could see me, but I could not see her. She would touch me, but I would rarely touch her. I was just on the other side of my skin. There, but not there. The ultimate sex toy. But not a partner.

I'd check in sometimes, but not often enough. I didn't recognize my boredom for what it was. Not a lack of activity, but a lack of capacity to just be. So I would go to #FKAgirlfriend's place, and as long as I was doing a thing, I was okay. I'd read a book, or cook a meal for us, or watch a TV show or movie, or write a blog post about all the things I was doing. But I still wasn't there, in between things. I'd started showing up in the real world for activity time, but I still went home to nowhere.

The most horrible thing in each of those places was me.

Prior to figuring out that I was a girl, I was present as little as possible. I couldn't even deal with sitting around and socializing, I couldn't just be where I was. I had to be doing a thing, and as soon as that thing was over, I needed to be doing another thing. I was an actual waste of space — a person-sized nothing person. I was holding space for the person I'd ultimately find myself to be, though I didn't know it at the time. I was a placeholder, a bookmark for Sera. I was always doing a thing, or asleep. I didn't rest, because I didn't know how.

After figuring out that I was a girl, I was present for thing-doing, but still not in between. I could do things, and I could talk about the things I'd been doing, but I had a very, very hard time not doing anything at all. #FKAgirlfriend broke up with me, and literally as I am writing this now today, nearly five months later, I realize that that was probably why. How lonely it must have been for her. Kim, if you can see this, please know how sorry I am to have put you through that. I'm sure I was with you sometimes. And I'm sure it wasn't nearly often enough. I was always doing a thing, or asleep. I didn't rest, because I didn't know how.

I started yoga classes at the VA. Some of the poses were challenging, but the hardest thing to do was lie there and just breathe. Even with the difficult balance poses, and the particulars of form, I was still doing a thing. I was learning yoga, memorizing transitions and techniques. But those first and last five minutes are still the hardest parts of the whole routine. At the beginning, I want to hurry up and yoga. At the end, I want to hurry up and finish yoga so I can do other things. I want to be doing a thing, or asleep. I don't rest. Because I don't know how.

A few weeks ago, I made a new rule for myself: when I am eating, I am eating. Not reading, or playing a game, or even talking to anybody.

A few days ago, I started noticing that I hadn't been following my new rule. Last night, I noticed that it had been all day that I'd broken it. I was transferring some bulk candies I'd bought at Winco the other day from their plastic bags, into some of the little mason jars I'd bought to hold weed. I was about to eat a few of the curry candied cashews, because they were higher than the lid line, when I remembered my new rule. I shut my monitor off, and I put one in my mouth.

I felt the moment the thin, waxy coating broke, when the flavors really came alive. I felt juices going everywhere, which was impossible, of course. As I thought, "how like a grape this is!" I realized that it was my own saliva, my body making more in response to this food. Enough of the candy coating melted away that a little bit of the cashew was exposed to my tongue.  There was firmness that wouldn't give way like the coating had. It invited a bite. I bit down and a new flavor was added. It was nutty, roasted, but also creamy. I thought it would be wonderful with some coconut milk. I sat and chewed, content.

I looked at the jar, and saw a few deformed ones. They'd been partially melted, taking on the shape of the part of the bag that had been pressed against them by Wobblefoot, whose pillow I'd left the bag on. I checked the top and saw that it was still a tiny bit over. I recognized that I wasn't really hungry, but that I wouldn't mind another, so I put another one in my mouth. I smiled and let it dissolve a bit for a moment while I put the lid on the jar, and sat back with my eyes closed. I shifted my focus between my breath and the cashew until the cashew was gone. And then I noticed how very, very tired I was.

I turned my monitor on and checked the time. It was just after 8p. "So early!" I thought. And then I remembered that I worked in a confectionery, and that I had to get up at 3:30 each morning, Monday through Friday, to be able to get there on time. I turned my monitor off, brushed my teeth, and went to bed. I woke up at about 5:30 this morning.

I pet my cats. I played my guitar. I did some yoga (and those first and last five minutes are still really hard). I had some yogurt while doing nothing else. I smoked a bowl with #MyFirstBong, and sat on the porch. I looked out at the sky, partly cloudy, and I made a point of not mentally blocking out #GingerAl's car. I came back inside to find Something Black growling at Pokey. I led Pokey away and got him interested in a toy instead. And then I sat down to write.

I realized this morning that I'd been homeless most of my life.

Sunday, June 19, 2016

Learning to Fly

I've been meaning to write something for release today for about two weeks. And none of the ideas I could think of for theme or intent or anything of that sort panned out. I mean, I'm certain that someone, somewhere, if I were to post a sort of dispassionate analysis of what it was like growing up with my dad, would say "a-HA! See? This is why you think you're a girl," which is cute. I can't think of another word for it. It's cute in the same way it was cute when Bailey, my middle child, wanted the hotel swimming pool to be warmer, and I told him to just keep swimming and he'd warm up. He came back to me about 10 minutes later and said, "Daddy, I warmed up the pool!" Adorable.

I'd write more about playing the part of dad with my own kids, but there's no good way for me to do that without talking about their other mother. Perhaps by next year, I'll have figured out a way to tell those stories effectively, while still deliberately leaving so much out. The anecdote above doesn't require context. But if I string enough of them together, they'll open up conversations that I can't have, because I've resolved to do my best to speak as little as possible about their other mother publicly.

So instead, I'm going to just sort of ramble about growing up with my dad. I'm a self-motivated, unpaid blogger, so I think this will be okay, the rambliness. Like, I'm not going to upset any advertisers. I certainly won't feel like I've ripped anyone off. If you've ever wondered what child-me was like, wonder no more. These are my memories of my father, who is still alive, last I checked. We interact sometimes on Facebook, but we're not Friends, which I think is appropriate, since we're not friends, either. My niece set up a private group for blood relatives, and we're both in it. In the last ten years, we've probably had fewer than ten minutes of interaction of any kind.

When I was maybe seven years old or so, my dad and I went on a road trip. I don't remember much about it at all. I don't know why my mom or my older brother weren't there. I think we were probably in Wisconsin, but I'm not sure. I know we were in my dad's Chevy Cavalier station wagon. It was sort of light blue. I made him put the seats down in the back so I could lie down on them like it was a bed, just two front seats and a bed, flying down the highway. It was winter, and the landscape was bleak and sleepy.


I had a cassette with Pink Floyd's "Learning to Fly" on it, and I didn't want to listen to anything else. I made that poor man listen to this song and nothing else for six or eight hours while I warbled along, not knowing most of the words. I don't know how he felt about it at the time, or if he even remembers it now.

That's the only purely happy memory I have with my dad. It's happy because he permitted me to be myself for a few hours, a few hours in which my mom was not around to criticize either of us. Maybe he enjoyed seeing me be free, I don't know. Maybe he couldn't wait to get back to my mom, who would never have permitted me to listen to any song I liked while I laid on my back in a beat-up station wagon and sang along. Not for five minutes, never mind five or more hours.

From what I understand now, today, my dad is basically playing along with the fact of my gender. Family of mine that are around him more have said that they think he doesn't actually believe I'm a girl, but that I'm just doing all this for attention; that that's the way he is behaving. Which makes sense, since his media diet is just about entirely Fox News, I'm told. I wonder if he worries I'm a danger to anyone. I wonder whether he worries about the danger I'm in; I mean, I really wonder, because I don't think he does. What a tremendously sad thought.

I've read and heard elsewhere that long-term depression can have severe impact on memory. I can't remember where I've read or heard that, though, which I think is hilarious. Anyway, the point is that I'm not exaggerating when I say I remember almost nothing from before I was about 15. Instead of an endless stream of human joys and sorrows to pull from and reflect upon, I have something more like an edited 90-second reel, a trailer that barely makes sense. Some kind of art film that leaves viewers with a sense of disconnected sadness, but no real idea what was happening.

I have a not-purely-happy memory of going somewhere else alone with my dad, on a family vacation to the American Southwest. I was probably about 12. We'd gone to Four Corners and the Grand Canyon and such. One morning, my mom wanted us to all get up before dawn to watch the sunrise before breakfast. It was important to her, so it must therefore be important to us. But what was important to me was sleeping in, and reading more God Emperor of Dune when I woke up. She threatened that I'd get nothing to eat until dinner if I didn't get up, and I refused, so they all left and I stayed in bed. Eventually, I woke up, and I laid there reading until they returned. I felt a little bit grown up, but mostly I felt like a kid who'd finally gotten her way about something, anything. I read more of Hwi Noree's tale, and lost myself in her life, so preferable to mine, even with all the danger and intrigue hers had.

They returned eventually, and my mom went on and on about how I'd really missed out. My dad wanted to go see Pikes Peak, and I was bored of sitting in the hotel room by then, so I asked if I could go with him. My mom and my brother didn't want to go, so they stayed behind, but my mom warned my dad not to buy me anything to eat, and this is probably how I came best to understand the concept of foreshadowing.

We drove up to the summit, and went into the gift shop. I pointed out all the things I wanted or thought were interesting. He bought me a small stuffed animal ram with comically large horns made of corduroy. Just the horns; the rest was ordinary plush. He bought me a little bit of fudge that they made on-site. Thinking I was a terribly clever kid, I named my ram Horny; a joke I was barely old enough to get. I wanted my parents to roll their eyes and laugh about how smart I was to make such a grown-up pun. We drove back to the hotel, and I carried a happiness with me whose fragility I did not understand.

Once my mom learned that my dad had not only allowed me to eat, but had facilitated it, the rest of the day, at least, was ruined. Maybe it was the next several days, I don't know, I don't remember. I remember my mom screaming bloody murder at him for what he'd done. I remember him mumbling, looking at the floor, shuffling his feet. I remember being yelled at for naming my stuffed animal Horny. My clever joke was offensive, but what I didn't understand at the time was that it was really only offensive because my mom was mad that my dad hadn't obeyed her.

When I was in high school, my dad walked through the kitchen early one weekday morning. He was in briefs, and nothing else, which was just how he was in the mornings. He saw me sitting there on a stool at the island (it was more of a peninsula, actually), wrapped in heavy blankets, eating cereal, barely awake. He patted me on the head, and said, "you're kinda weird." Then he went to take his shower and get ready for work.

Much later, during the first block of eight or so years in which I did not speak to my parents, I was back in Michigan for a friend's wedding. My wife at the time, Dimple, sought a rapprochement between my parents and me. The nearest I could bring myself was to drive past their house, my childhood home. I saw my dad riding the lawnmower, staring vacantly into space as he ponderously whirlpooled around the yard. He'd come to some central point about three hours after he started, I estimated. Just like I used to. I missed cutting the grass, that chore I used to hate. He didn't see me. And I never stopped.

Sunday, May 8, 2016

Other Mother

One of the great gifts of my transness is that I am forced, constantly, as a matter of course, to try to explain my existence around the context of existing social constructs that naturally exclude me. And being forced to do that, without pause, without rest, has led me to some different views of reality. It's not that I think I have the best possible view of reality. We all have our own view of it, and mine, like yours, is necessarily limited and defined by my own experience. But so much of what comprises my view of reality these days is an understanding that I will never, ever be able to see all of it.

So, with that, today, I am asking myself, more pointedly, a series of questions I have had mulling around in the background for almost two years. Am I a father? Am I a mother? Am I both? Neither? Have I always been all of those things, in some way? What is a mother?

One common refrain I hear is that simply contributing to the birth of a child is not what makes one a mother or a father. So, in that regard, the fact that I contributed sperm and not egg to create three children has no real meaning or value. It has genetic value, but not social value. I had to do more than that to be a father. I had to do something other than that to be a mother. I fathered children in the genetic sense, but that wasn't what made me a father. And while I agree with that construct, I find it darkly amusing that I have the same problem here as I have elsewhere when it comes to gender. We use the same words to mean different things. We say "father" when we mean "contributor of sperm, and nothing else," and when we mean "male child-rearing person, and nothing else." Often, people are both. But sometimes they are one or the other. Like gender and sex, when we use the same word to define different things, it's easy to see how quickly things become confused.

One way to think of "father" is "male role model." This is the definition people are leaning on when they say someone is "a father to us all." They're saying that the man in question is the kind of man every man should aspire to be like. And while I tried to be that for my own kids, I realize now that if I was always female (true), then I could never have actually been a male role model, for anyone. I certainly tried my best. But trying to be the best version of something I could not be doesn't change the fact that I could not be that thing. I could not show them how to be a man. I could only show them how to pretend to be one.

That's not to say that I showed my kids malignant examples of manhood. Just that all I could ever show them was a drawing, a schematic, an idea of what it might be. It was a poor idea, based on poor data, like the account of a disoriented eyewitness. I essentially said, "this is what a man is supposed to be. Right? I think?" There is literally nothing about masculinity or being a man that I can inherently understand.

So, did I show them an alternate kind of motherhood, or womanhood? A version of motherhood that was dressed up to look like fatherhood? What's the difference?

Does it matter?

I have to back up further and ask myself that question. Because I think that all the questions before that are rooted in this notion that every child needs a mother and a father, in the role-model sense. But when I think of myself, I realize that having a dad meant nothing to me, in terms of having a male role model. How ever much I ended up being like him, I never set out to be like my dad, because his life and his dreams were never mine. But that would've been true even if I'd been born cisgender female. And it's also true of my own mom.

In that sense, I don't have parents. And I've become more comfortable with that than with the idea of adopting new ones. I've become comfortable with the idea of having come from nowhere. Or at least from nowhere I can identify or place or give name to. It's a place that precedes modern cultural definitions of gender because I have always existed outside of those definitions.

From there, it makes more sense to argue that we aren't mothers or fathers, any of us, but simply parents. But to argue that is to stop before passing that boundary back into gendered space, where I acknowledge that there is an aspect to human reality that we all share: that my gender is core to who I am, and it matters. Even agender people, those who are genderless, have that property as a core element of who they are: existing as not-gender can only be expressed in relation to gender. Gender is inescapable.

So if I am a parent (true) and I am a woman (true) and being a woman and a parent are both core to who I am (true), and those are things shared by a number of other people (probably true) then it's reasonable to define this category of person, "mother," as "woman who is a parent" or "parent who is a woman." And it's reasonable to define "father" similarly, for men. But I also fathered children, genetically, so I'm kind of back to square one. Am I a father? Am I a mother? Am I both? Neither? Have I always been all of those things, in some way? What is a mother?

At the end of my post last year on Mother's Day, I somewhat flippantly stated that for all those who feel they have no mother, for whatever reason, that I was their mother, now. And a couple people have taken me up on that with some seriousness.

I can't quite remember how I ended up with two "adopted" daughters, but I know it was through a series of Third Eye Blind fan groups I have been a part of on Facebook. The younger of the two, Brittnie, is still in touch with her biological mother. But Brittnie's mom has always struggled with addiction, and has never been reliable for her in any way. I had probably said to her something like what I said at the end of last year's Mother's Day blog post — that since she didn't feel like she had a mom, I was her mom, now, too bad, haha. But it was real to her, and it's become real to me, too.

She came to me for solace and advice as she struggled to come to terms with the end of her marriage. She came to me because she needed a mom, and that is who she understands me to be. Her daughters, whom I regard as granddaughters, call me "Grandma Sera." I know that at 41 this should make me feel old and disregarded, culturally, but it has the opposite effect for me. I'm in this remarkable position of being able to finally grow up as a girl, alongside girls of all different ages. From my granddaughters, to my friend Liz, who just turned 16; to the many women I befriended this time around at college, who are generally in their mid-20s; to my other daughter, Olivia, in her early 30s; and even to women my own age, or nearly so, like my high school friends Kelly and Deanna, whom I only recently reconnected with. I get to grow as a woman in the context of other women, and I get the advantage of all this life experience that I collected but never processed. I get to take apart and digest every old trauma that even slightly resembles theirs, and we get to grow up a little bit, together.

Of all the wonderful and amazing ways in which women in general have welcomed me as a woman, this has been by far the most profound. I don't feel disregarded, I feel connected. I feel like I'm part of some great sprawling tree of womanhood, that there are parts that gave rise to me and my place, and that I in turn give rise to that in others. And it turns out nothing makes me feel younger at 41 than unboxing and getting over something I should've figured out when I was 21. That Liz should say to me, "I really do look up to you as a role model for the woman I want to be, and I'm glad I met you" makes my chest burst. It makes me want to keep aspiring to be that, to be my own ideal conception of woman. Not to just exist as woman, which I would do no matter what, but to step beyond that primordial sea and onto land, towards the sky.

Does that make me a mother? Yes. Because now I've figured it out.

I am a mother because I am a parent and I am female. We are mothers if anyone sees us as such. Sometimes that's the racing heartbeat of a scared, pregnant 13-year-old, coming to terms with the idea of themselves as a mother, before anyone else knows. Sometimes it's the recently-out trans man with adult children. Sometimes it's the 41-year-old trans woman with two daughters who have never known her as anyone but who she always was. Sometimes it's me, acknowledging to myself that I am a woman who is also a parent, which is also known as "mother."

"Mother" is an observed relationship. And if anyone observes it, anyone at all, even if it's only you, then congratulations, you have it. Happy Mother's Day.

Tuesday, April 12, 2016

Catch

I know I keep coming back to this, but, humor me. I turn 41 today, and I am feeling retrospective.

Phantasy Star Online, an online multiplayer reboot of a favorite Sega franchise of mine from when I'd been a kid, came out for Dreamcast on January 29, 2001. Not much later, I was laid off from Business.com, after the company I'd been working for was bought out entirely by them. In the intervening months before I found my next job, I was miserable. I was married, but unhappily so, as you might expect. Without any capacity for joy, or being fully present as myself, my first wife and I were unable to truly connect; I was, essentially, not there at all. The first real clear signs that I would let my life fall apart and feel powerless to stop it showed themselves during that layoff period. I mostly sat around playing PSO, inventing character after character, story after story. I didn't look for work. Work looked for me.

There were plenty of class variants to choose from, but the character type that fascinated me most was, of course, the robotic girl — the RAcaseal. I made several, ultimately, including the protagonist of this tale. But the first of them was Sera, with her purple plated skirt. She was the first iteration of a character that would leave PSO's universe entirely, and grow into the original concept that I ultimately called Seranine. Though my Dreamcast, that first copy of PSO, and nearly all of the rest of my game collection was stolen out of a storage locker a few years ago, I had the VMUs until I dumped all of the rest of what I had on my tumblr friend, Liz.

This is an older story of mine. It can be found online at fanfiction.net, but even the date on that post is misleading; I'd taken the original post down to dissociate it from an online identity of mine that had been compromised by an ex, and then republished it as dubsyubsy. I published it earlier than January 8, 2011, though I can't remember exactly how much earlier. It's probably from somewhere near the time of the release of the X-Box and Gamecube versions of Phantasy Star Online, in late 2002 or early 2003.

Enjoy.



"Bluefull, huh. Funny section for a Ranger," said the Teleporter Security Agent.

"I am what I am," Catch replied.

The agent snorted. "A caseal with a sense of humor. What next?" he asked rhetorically. "You're clear," he said, pausing to examine her information one last time, "Miss... Catch."

"It's just 'Catch,'" she said tonelessly, disconnecting her link from his terminal, and moving on to the teleporter.

With only token resistance remaining on the area of Ragol's surface selected by Pioneer 1 for settlement, and the ruins secured and mostly void of hostile creatures, Pioneer 2 was back on a landing schedule at last. Both ships were designed to land once, then be taken apart and repurposed as the beginnings of the refugees' first city on Ragol. With the majority of Pioneer 1's parts scattered across the surface as useless scrap, Pioneer 2's operators knew that they'd have to ration very carefully.

Word of the loss of Pioneer 1 and all her passengers and crew had not yet been officially released, but there were few who clung hopefully to the government line that an investigation was still in progress. Rumors had spread, and most of the populace had accepted the fact that, at best, those friends and family who had gone ahead on the first ship were now dead.

Catch, an average-sized RAcaseal with a white chassis and blue and yellow details, was, like most casts, without family. And, like most casts, she had difficulty making friends. Nearly all casts, aboard Pioneer 2 or otherwise, were endowed with an artificial intelligence. While logic was, in relative terms, simple to impart, emotion proved far more elusive. Basic drives were applied as overriding parameters, to create the illusion of, for example, a forgiving nature, or obsession. The reality remained the same; most casts were able to apply or deactivate these pseudo-emotion parameters, as they deemed appropriate.

A much less common form of cast, though the original type, is one whose intelligence is not artificial in the purest sense. While it is uploaded and stored as any other data, this consciousness is taken from a previously organic being. Frowned upon by more religious elements of society as a form of hubris, this essentially offers the being a sort of immortality. Often, this doesn't last. Most of these casts end up destroying themselves, heedless of the advantages that a robotic body provides, longing only to truly touch, taste, smell, and feel again.

Catch is the former type. What the agent saw as a dry humor was simply the barest interpersonal reaction required by Catch's programming, neither accepting nor rejecting his comment, only acknowledging it. Advanced though her emotional algorithms were, they remained just that; algorithms. Attempts to define illogical behavior patterns as logical cascades of events. Most of the time, Catch left these social tools inactive. Her few attempts at truly social interaction led her quickly to the conclusion that her purposes were rarely served by such activity.

Presently, her purpose was another routine sweep of the ancient ruins beneath the more recent ruins of Pioneer 1.

When Pioneer 1 exploded, the force shook more than Ragol's surface. Pioneer 2, in a close orbit, was rocked by shockwaves. Its modular design strained the monstrous cast that held the ships together, and portions of the ship actually broke away from the central core. While each collection of ships that broke away was self-sufficient, it made communication across all of Pioneer 2 more difficult.

The first piece to break away from the Dreamcast, or "DC," was a relatively small cube-shaped collection of ships, which came to be called the Cube. A larger, more rectangular group of ships broke away a few hours later, and came to be known as the Box. Their varying sizes and power ultimately caused these three collections to orbit the planet at different speeds, making collaboration between their populations, civilian or otherwise, nearly impossible.

Fortunately, for Hunters on the Cube and the Box, this separation meant an increase in work. Though the planet's surface, at least in the area the Pioneer settlement defined, was mostly vacant, a few stray altered beasts, malfunctioning mining robots, and other such hostile elements posed a sporadic threat. With the accidental independence from the DC gained by the Box and the Cube when Pioneer 2 was split in three, responsibility for assuring safety within the regions to be settled by each part of Pioneer 2, and for ensuring that an area of appropriate size was available for the ship when dismantled, was now shouldered by three practically independent governing bodies.

Unfortunately for the rest of the Box and the Cube's population, the breaking points with the bulk of Pioneer 2 contained critical areas. The Cube went for nearly a month without air pressure or temperature controls, though the government luckily managed to quickly arrange jury-rigged airtight seals that held long enough to get most of the population into environmental suits. The Box lost its medical center and all staff who were on-site at the time of the split. This left its new medical center woefully understaffed.

While the major ships represented by the DC had sufficient population to stick to the same three Hunter subclasses for the same three major Hunter classes, officials on the Cube and the Box, short on resources, elected to let some of the previously restricted Hunter subclasses in on the action. Waves of RAmarls, HUcaseals, and even FOmars were suddenly not only useful, but sought-after.

When the Central Dome of Pioneer 1, reconfigured to be an administrative building, exploded, the resultant panic on Pioneer 2 was difficult to deal with. In time, it became easier, as missions to regain control of the surface took on a routine air. Eventually, with the area comprising the Pioneer settlement controlled again by the colonists, a question that had been avoided with relative ease throughout the battle to win back the land was bubbling back up to the surface.

Where were the bodies?

In the early stages of arrival, as territorial progress continued, friends and relatives of those who manned Pioneer 1 grew increasingly agitated, at turns hoping for news, or glad that the struggle was continuing, allowing them to imagine an impending reunion or some other happy ending. Now that rumors had spread that the ruins had been won, the buzzing grew louder every day.

Throughout the struggle, it had gone without saying that Pioneer 1's crew and passengers would turn up in one way or another. Either their bodies would be found, or, as Pioneer 2's few optimists suggested, they would be holed up somewhere, perhaps surviving without the benefit of Pioneer 1's shelters, or as prisoners of the evil that was surely guiding the hostility of Ragol's denizens. With the ruins cleared, and even more dangerous areas of the forests and caves coming under greater control with each passing day, people became puzzled at best.

As such, part of the job description for the routine patrols of controlled areas was, in relatively small type, to investigate any leads that could point the way to the optimistically labeled "survivors" of Pioneer 1. The closest anyone had come was the recovery of Red Ring Rico's eponymous bracelet, flung with its owner's lifeless body from the crippled husk of the monster, dubbed "Dark Falz," at the heart of the ruins. This suggested something extremely unpleasant.

After having laid waste to hordes of dark enemies, some Hunters came to the sickening realization that it was entirely possible that those faceless horrors were in fact the crew and passengers of Pioneer 1, transformed somehow into representations of Dark Falz's spirit. This theory was proposed, through the Hunters' Guild, to the government of Pioneer 2 before the ship was divided. Without any evidence to back the theory up, the Principal did his best to keep it quiet. While situation wasn't ideal, the timing of the division of Pioneer 2 was a fortuitous coincidence, as it effectively restricted ever-wilder rumor versions of the theory to the DC ships.

Hunters were asked to re-investigate Ragol, especially the ruins, for any evidence that could support the transformation theory. Prior to the appearance of Rico's body and bracelet, the only thing suggesting that Pioneer 1's crew had even penetrated the ruins was the abundance of supply boxes scattered throughout the structure. While it struck some as odd that the lumbering hulks, which invariably struck directly in melee, would sometimes drop extremely rare and valuable canes, rifles, and even technique disks, this was easily dismissed as a mass coincidence. With dimenians in thankfully short supply, there were no subjects to study. It was posited that the monsters killed the colonists, and simply carried their possessions as primitive trophies. Without evidence to the contrary, this seemed to be a more rational theory than the transformation concept, absent remains notwithstanding.

As Catch entered another abandoned chamber in the ruins, her CPU continued to spin over the possible fates of Pioneer 1's crew and passengers. Reviewing the footage from the epic battle with Dark Falz, she stopped to consider the details of the sudden reappearance of Rico's body. The body had been ejected from Dark Falz as it collapsed, shortly before it, like the dimenians and other hostiles on Ragol, simply dissolved into a puddle of jelly. This suggested, Catch realized, that if the colonists were somehow taken over by Dark Falz, it might have been a process of envelopment rather than one of transformation. Tests on the gelatinous matter that remained when a Ragolian hostile was destroyed revealed high concentrations of dangerously corrosive acids. If the colonists were in fact encased in the dimenian husks, their bodies would have, in all likelihood, simply dissolved along with their shell.

Her revelation was transmitted to the Hunters' Guild and logged, like the rest of her thoughts. She briefly considered marking it "important," so that it would be examined rather than simply logged, but instead opted to search for evidence to support her extension of the current theory before pushing to get any Hunters to change their mission parameters.

Nobody had ever considered capturing one of the vicious, mindless residents of the ruins. Often, it was difficult to simply survive an encounter with one. In order to support her envelopment theory, Catch surmised, she'd have to find a way to essentially skin one of the dark monsters alive. Somehow, the inside would have to be exposed in a way that did not fatally wound the creature. She decided that her Photon Launcher's paralyzing extra attack would be the best option. An ice trap was out of the question, because the ice casing would prevent her from operating on the frozen body within. The Photon Launcher wouldn't give her much time, but with the creature unable to strike, she calculated she would likely have just enough of a window to draw a brand and cut off a single extremity, exposing the inside of the creature without killing it. If she saw red anywhere in the roiling purple, she'd be assured that she was onto something.

Now, there was the matter of actually finding a dimenian.


She drew its attention to her position near the door with a few stray shots from her lockgun. As the dimenian lumbered towards her with ever-increasing momentum, mindlessly driven to destroy the intruder, she put the lockgun away and drew the massive Photon Launcher. Catch steadied herself to counterbalance the heavy kick of the slow-firing weapon.

Catch opened fire on the dimenian just as it came into the Photon Launcher's range. Its penetrating shots barely phased the creature. It jerked with each impact, but its pace was barely altered. A living thing might have cursed in such a situation, but as the dimenian entered no-quarter range, Catch mechanically let the Photon Launcher fall back over her right shoulder, where she had mounted it. Before it hit the ground, she drew her brand, and activated it as she brought it up to meet the dimenian's downward-swinging right arm.

Her servos whined in protest as the brand locked with the dimenian's arm. Sparks flew from where her brand met the dimenian's bladed arm. They flew from her feet as she was pushed back across the floor by the dimenian's brute strength. Every motor in her body was dedicated to the defensive stance she had been forced into. Her legs were wide apart, her feet firmly planted, and she leaned into her bent left leg to absorb the pressure put on by the dimenian. Sparks began to fly from her left shoulder as motors reached their load limit and failed. As the dimenian moved to stab her with its left arm, she was forced to improvise.

A damage trap dropped from Catch's back. She spun down and to her left, letting the dimenian's right arm finish its swing. This unbalanced the dimenian, which stopped its stabbing left arm and flung it out to its side to keep itself upright. As the creature brought its right arm back up and began a sideswiping motion, Catch, still whirling, drew her lockgun with her left hand and fired at the trap, detonating it. The dimenian was again thrown off-balance, and Catch used the momentum from her spinning motion and the dimenian's initial strike to bring the brand down hard on its upper right arm.

Her swing uninterrupted, Catch was certain that she had missed the mark. She came down hard on her right foot, with her back to the dimenian, her left knee on the ground, and her right thigh pressed against her chest. To keep herself from falling over altogether, she opened her sword hand, slamming the brand's handle into the ground beneath her palm. Her left arm dangled beside her, the hand still clutching the lockgun. And then she saw the dimenian's severed right blade arm, at two-thirds of its length from the shoulder, land just behind her.

The brand flickered and went out, the impact with the ground rendering it inoperable. Catch rose quickly, shifted the lockgun to her right hand, her left arm now useless, and trained it on the stunned dimenian. Streams of red and purple fluid dripped from its partially cauterized wound.

Catch leapt backwards through the door as the dimenian stumbled towards her, lunging with its left arm aimed at her chest. She braced herself for the struggle to break free from the blade, which was certain to impale her. Instead, as the tip of its bladed arm crossed the threshold, the creature cried out with greater volume than any dimenian had ever produced. Its momentum too great to stop, the dimenian shrieked and twisted in midair as it found itself thrown outside its room by its own off-balance rush. Catch watched dispassionately as the chitinous surface seemed to age a hundred years in a fraction of a beat.

As the dimenian's body struck the ground, its torso in the hallway, its legs still in the room, its shell cracked and shattered. Billions of minute purple crystals poured out of the maze of cracks in the dimenian's carapace. Whole pieces of its armored exoskeleton disintegrated, and the purple crystals grew finer and finer until they seemed to disappear entirely. Pale white skin began to break through the mass of purple and black dust.

The creature inside lifted its torso off the ground with its left arm, its eyes glowing, and howled as the last of the dimenian torso disintegrated. It pulled itself further into the hallway. The dimenian's legs underwent the same transformation, seemingly losing all moisture, then all substance. Left behind was a pale, hairless, naked female form that slowly curled into a ball around its partially severed right arm, and then lay motionless.

Determining that the threat had passed, Catch retrieved her Photon Launcher, and collected surface samples from where the dimenian form had disintegrated. Then she snapped open a telepipe, picked the woman up, and stepped through the portal to Pioneer 2.


Dr. Reya Abbingham, one of the Box's few surviving medical doctors, was the first thing that Julie-Anne Valentine, the first known being to be freed from a dimenian shell, had seen with her own eyes in some time.

It had been nearly one month since her unwilling battle with Catch, and she had been, for most of that time, only able to distinguish brightness levels and colors. While Reya's voice was familiar to her, after hundreds of beats of careful explanation of the physiological changes she had undergone when taken over by the dimenian, Julie had not been able to see her clearly until now.

The second thing she examined was her cybernetic right hand. The bionic prosthetic extended halfway up her forearm, replacing the part of her body that had been cut off when Catch sliced through the dimenian's upper arm.

"You were fortunate that the photon blade cut so cleanly," Reya said, taking a seat beside Julie's bed, facing her. "It made replacing your hand a relatively simple operation."

Julie offered a thin, forced smile. Her pale skin was still smooth and hairless over most of her body, though her scalp showed signs of impending hair growth. She was still emaciated, in spite of the constant intravenous flow of nutrients she had been supplied with since Catch had first brought her onto the Box. She had regained much of her strength and form, but her lengthy encapsulation had left her wiry and thin, seemingly unable to gain much weight.

"I've got a video conference with Principal Tyrell that's set to start in about 30 beats, when our collections are within range of each other, but I can keep you company until then. How are we feeling today, better?" Reya asked.

"Sure," Julie replied, her gaze returning to the foot of her bed and losing focus again. The awkward silence that followed left the room with Reya.


"You may be wondering why, with the relative abundance of enemy body parts we retrieved and turned into weapons using the Montague process, this envelopment was not discovered sooner," Reya continued, nearly two hundred beats into her debriefing of Principal Tyrell. The 250-beat window of signal clarity between the DC and the Box would not last much longer, but she was nearing the end of her report.

"Go on," Tyrell said.

"From the seventeen additional colonists that have been captured as dimenian creatures and excised in the ruins since Catch's encounter with the dimenian Ms. Valentine, we can see that the dramatic variance in form accounts for the equally varied size of the colonists who were caught in the energy wave. As you can see," she said, indicating an overlay showing a humanoid form and a dimenian form, "the dimenian casing is substantially larger than the human or newman inside. Ms. Valentine's arm was severed cleanly through the ulna, which corresponded to what would have been the humerus of the dimenian, were it an endoskeletal creature."

"Notice that not all encapsulations are so directly laid out as the basic dimenians," Reya went on, indicating a new slide that showed an infant and a young child. "These gunner dimenians encased infants, while the delsabers held young children. Notice that in neither case do the limbs of the encased being correlate in any way to the limbs of the dimenian shell."

"Mm-hmm," Tyrell grunted. "And the chaos bringers and chaos sorcerers?"

"Chaos bringers were a combination of the dimenian energy and some of the livestock aboard Pioneer 1. The bulk of the humanoid portion is dimenian. As you can see, the animal inside was held at an angle that forced it to essentially look upwards through the top of the chaos bringer's head. The sorcerers appear to have been made from some of the more gifted Forces on Pioneer 1, whose magical energy was not fully contained by the dimenian envelopment process."

"Help me to understand this, Dr. Abbingham," Tyrell said. "You're saying that the explosion that caused Pioneer 1 to lose contact with us was not only a physical event, but also a metaphysical one?"

"Yes."

"And during this event, in your words, 'living or sentient things from Pioneer 1 within range of the explosion were effectively possessed' by a 'wave of dimenian energy' that then..." he paused, "'manifested itself physically as an exoskeleton' which... 'bent their wills' to those of an unknown master, which we presume to be this 'Dark Falz'?"

"Correct," came Reya's instant reply.

"Ms. Valentine's reappearance reveals several aspects of the nature of Dark Falz and the dark, or 'dimenian,' energy that were previously unknown," Reya continued. "Perhaps most interesting was the reason why none of the creatures overtaken by Dark Falz's spirit were ever known to leave the chambers in which they appeared. The power that binds the colonists' forms to their dimenian husks appears to be directly tied to the space in which the envelopment took place. In spite of however much the colonist inside a dimenian wants to leave a room, the husk will not allow it. Once removed from the space that conducted Dark Falz's spiritual energy," she continued, indicating the video sequence from Catch's meeting with Valentine's dimenian form, "the dimenian husk loses integrity and is sloughed off."

"That is interesting, doctor," Tyrell interjected, "but I need you to clarify something implied earlier."

"Of course," Reya replied.

"Do you mean to tell me that all of the people from Pioneer 1 who were... enveloped by this wave of energy from Dark Falz, who subsequently unwillingly engaged our investigators are, in absolute terms, dead?"

Reya paused. "Yes. If the dimenian shell is damaged beyond a certain point, it collapses on itself and is quickly dissolved by the highly acidic fluids inside. The few colonists that remain in the ruins as dimenians can be saved with a concerted effort to lure them to a doorway and then expel them from the room in which they -" she continued, but Principal Tyrell had already stopped listening. As she finished sharing the rest of her findings, he pondered his situation with growing dread. He was now faced with the task of telling thousands of people that the investigation he had ordered had led directly to the deaths of nearly everyone aboard Pioneer 1. More than that, he was left with a sinking feeling that it was his own dead daughter's insatiable curiosity that had started it all.



Catch, like other stories I'd been writing, dealt with issues of a good spirit trapped inside a bad body, compelled to act in ways that did not feel right or natural. It also, through the persona of Catch, herself, shows a kind of bitter gratitude for the robotic shell that ultimately saves Julie-Anne Valentine. As for Julie-Anne, though I'd thought at the time that Catch was the analog for myself, I would now say that Catch is the analog for the Jason Construct, while Julie-Anne is the analog for Seranine. One protects and ultimately helps free the other, who is then left to be, in many ways, born again, or reset, physically. Julie-Anne also has to lose a part of herself, which is replaced with a manufactured substitute, in order to be fully freed from her former monstrous body.

Even the character name, Catch, was derived from the programming work I was doing. She's an exception-handler, an error correction routine.

I thought it was interesting that I built the story atop Sega's original story, in which Red Ring Rico, the Principal's daughter, was the one whose curiosity "started it all," though I doubt the original canon game story was ever intentionally about a transgender experience. I had just unconsciously adapted it to be so. In trying to live up to her high family expectations, she is destroyed, only at the last freed from the horror of the body she was trapped in. But her death is a kind of martyrdom, because while it was preceded by the unwitting mass murder of Pioneer 1's colonists by their own people, the colonists and Hunters of Pioneer 2, her death was the first inkling anyone could have that perhaps all of those other beings, which had been regarded as monsters that needed to be put down, were actually loved ones. That in their rush to destroy what they feared and did not understand, the colonists of Pioneer 2 brought their own greatest grief upon themselves. In this conceit, their savior, the one who stops them from killing off every last one, is still another kind of constructed girl, Catch, herself.

I will have to dig through my old sketches to see if I can find some of my earlier original characters and story ideas. I vaguely recall writing more male characters when I was much younger, but by the time I'd hit puberty, I lost all interest in exploring male anything in my own fiction. Everything became variations of women being freed, or freeing themselves, from bodies and roles and expectations that had been laid upon them, often by forces far greater than them.

Thursday, March 31, 2016

What Is The Matrix?


17 years ago today, The Matrix went into wide release, and opened with those words on the big screen. 10 years later, the first Transgender Day of Visibility took place. Lilly Wachowski was outed as transgender recently. The idea of “Andy Wachowski,” like the idea of “Larry Wachowski,” like the idea of “Trinity,” was revealed to be a figment of someone’s imagination. A ghost, a cipher. I looked back on my own stories and songs I’d written before I realized I was a woman, and all the metaphorical ways in which I talked about a thing that I knew, even before I could understand it. Like any storyteller, every story I ever told was ultimately a story about myself. It struck me, as it had probably struck others before, that perhaps The Matrix as a franchise was basically one big metaphor for being transgender. And it is. And it isn’t.

The Matrix, as a franchise, is very much like a religious text. It is a tangled mass of parable and allegory, and it is open to interpretation. Mine probably differs from yours. But that does not mean the original authors did not have a meaning they were trying to convey. It just means that there is necessarily some signal loss, and sometimes that leads to unexpectedly beautiful things. It is, like any great story, a mirror. A mirror in which we can find ourselves.

When the first movie opens, we are shown that the world is not so plain and simple as we might like to believe. We see a woman defying gravity, among other basic rules, and we, as the audience, are given a point of view to share: that of the ordinary police officer, who sees Trinity and her pursuers doing things he knows nobody can do. “That’s impossible,” he says, giving voice to what we all think, what we all know, when we see a scene like that in a movie. People can’t actually do those things. There are rules.

We see the life of Thomas Anderson, but before that, we meet him as Neo, a hacker. He lives in apartment 101, the first level of new understanding. He thinks that, as a hacker, that he is subverting systems by exploiting their inherent, intrinsic weaknesses. And that’s true. But it’s not. There are larger systems layered upon that, as he soon learns.

He warns his customers that they must disavow his existence. He does not want the world to know he is Neo; Thomas Anderson knows that his life will be over if people find out who he really is. But Neo wants to be known and seen, he wants to share what makes him special. We know this because otherwise his customers could never have found him.

Does this make Neo a cipher for trans women? I thought so at first. But when Neo meets Trinity for the first time, he says, “I just thought, um… you were a guy.”

“Most guys do,” she counters.

Trinity is a cipher for the idea of trans women. She’s also a representation of sexism in tech, the assumption that if someone achieves something significant in STEM, they must be male. But more than that, she’s an expression of the idea that doing something perceived as masculine makes one somehow more male, less female. Yet, the facts of her skills have no bearing on her gender. So there she stands, a woman that “most guys” think is a guy, too. But if Neo isn’t a cipher for trans women, what is he a cipher for?

“The answer is out there, Neo,” Trinity tells him. “It’s looking for you. And it will find you, if you want it to.”

Truth finds us at least as often as we find Truth. For trans people, Truth has to find us, or at least it had to. Now that we are more and more visible in open society, it’s less incumbent upon trans people to realize they are trans in a vacuum. Even Neo had some help, and his help came from the network, too. It would keep coming, and every time, it comes from the fact that he is connected to others in ways he doesn’t always understand.

Neo returns to his “normal life” as Thomas Anderson. We can see how much he dislikes that life, we can see the resignation with which he grudgingly accepts it. How could he not? The Matrix has him. Or at least he believes it does. When a delivery person asks, “Thomas Anderson?” he sighs, and says, “yeah, that’s me.” We can see him deflate. We can see that Thomas Anderson isn’t Neo. He’s a cipher for Neo, a cover story, a ghost. He doesn’t exist. But that cover story, like any lie big enough, ultimately takes on a life of its own.

My experience as a trans woman before I knew that’s what I was was very much like Mr. Anderson’s. I tried to follow all the rules. I tried to deny who I was in order to get along, and do what I thought the system demanded of me. I created, without realizing it, an entire living, breathing persona that I have come to call The Jason Construct. It was the ultimate cover story, a shell that I tried to live inside.

But The Jason Construct was not me any more than my clothes are my body. And while the shell was comfortable enough to hide in when I was young, it soon became too tight, too constricting. After all, it had been designed to fit a child. That sense of nothing fitting quite right, that sense of alienation and disconnect and frustration with just trying to do what I thought I was supposed to be doing is something Neo felt, too. It’s the cognitive dissonance brought on by the conflict between who we are, and who we are told we must be.

The delivery person brings him a phone, and it rings the second he takes it out of the package. This is his first real struggle for authenticity. His connection to the out-group of the series, each of them ciphers for societal non-conformance of some kind or another, is one that he sought out as Neo, but one which terrifies and confuses Thomas Anderson. For Thomas Anderson to acknowledge openly that he is really Neo is an existential threat to Thomas Anderson, to that persona. Thus, the first system that Neo dismantles and breaks free from is not The Matrix, but Thomas Anderson.

But Neo felt it in a different way from me, in a way that I think is probably more common for trans people. And as he tries to escape the building later, as he wrestles with the indignity of being chased by police for being who he is, not understanding why, he says to himself, “this is insane. Why is this happening to me? What did I do? I’m nobody. I didn’t do anything. I’m gonna die.” Thomas Anderson, a ghost, a cipher, a figment of Neo’s imagination, tries to talk Neo out of being.

Even as he leans out the window and looks down at the street, there is a metaphor. When we are high up in our buildings, we feel safe and secure, as long as we do not think about how high up we actually are. As long as we do not think about how quickly everything could go wrong. About how there’s nothing in the world we can do about it if it does. Facing that reality can be terrifying. But being comfortable isn’t always a good thing. “I can’t do this,” he says to himself, and turns back, to be taken in by The Rules for daring to even think about existing outside of them.

This sequence is a cipher for being found out, by anyone who is acting as an Agent of The Matrix. Maybe it’s a wife discovering women’s clothing hidden away in her husband’s drawers. Maybe it’s a co-worker running into you at a club, while you’re out as some exploratory early iteration of the real you, and then threatening to out you to everyone, threatening to destroy your shell, the shell that you think you need in order to survive because you’ve only ever known one way to survive: by doing what you have been told to do from the moment you were born.

“It seems that you’ve been living… two lives,” Agent Smith begins, detailing the differences between Neo’s apparent life to those around him as Thomas Anderson, a respectable, ordinary, tax-paying citizen, under the name he was given, and Neo, a computer hacker, an outlaw whose crime is revealing flaws in systems that purport to serve everyone. “One of these lives has a future,” Smith goes on, “and one of them does not.”

Agent Smith then literally takes Neo’s voice away, compelling his mouth to seal itself, in a space that could only have been described as coercive even before that. This is Neo’s first real glimpse of The Matrix. This is the first time he begins to understand that the system whose flaws he has been revealing will defend itself vigorously from that existential assault. It does not defend itself directly. It defends itself through proxies. Agents.

As Neo reels in terror, Agent Smith permits himself a small smile. He revels in punishing anyone different from the norm, anyone different from him. Then they put the bug into Neo’s body, turning it against itself. The message is clear, here: we’re watching you. We are waiting to silence you and abuse you and punish you for not obeying The Rules. The system is bigger than you, they essentially say, and it works for everyone else, so go along, or be destroyed. What they don’t understand is that there is no choice. There is no “go along, or be destroyed.” There is only “go along, and be destroyed.”

They let him go, because as far as they can understand, there’s no reason not to. They can follow him anywhere, they can drag him back any time and silence him again. And he doesn’t understand it yet, but they can even erase all memory of him, of Neo, once he’s gone. They can brainwash him, with what some might liken to “conversion therapy,” and destroy him at the expense of preserving his shell. They will accept the thing that Neo made — Thomas Anderson — because it benefits the system. But they will reject Neo, because the system cannot tolerate threats to its existence. But even without understanding all of that, even without understanding just how wrong his perception of all reality really is, Neo knows he can’t keep living the way he has been. We see this play out as he considers leaving the car that Trinity picked him up in, looking down a dark alley in the rain.

“You have been down there, Neo. You know that road. You know exactly where it ends. And I know that’s not where you wanna be.” That road is the road of self-denial, and it is a miserable path that leads to suicide. Suicide, literal or spiritual. And when you get right down to it, nobody actually ever wants to die. We just talk ourselves into it, into not living, one way or another. Into going along, and being destroyed.

When we find a truth terrifying and we deny it, and try to get away from it, the character of that truth is not relevant to the fact of it. Truth is truth. When I first watched this scene again, for the first time in years, for the first time since Before I knew I was a woman, I broke down and cried. Because I know that road, too. I’ve been down there. That road is maddening, desperate, endless years of trying to be something I never was and never could be: a man. This nothing throwaway sequence is actually a crucial element of the entire story, a big giveaway about what this story is really about. And, like everything else about trans identity in mainstream culture, it is hidden in plain sight.

When they first meet, Morpheus says to Neo, “Let me tell you why you’re here. You’re here because you know something. What you know, you can’t explain. But you feel it. You’ve felt it your entire life. That there’s something wrong with the world. You don’t know what it is, but it’s there. Like a splinter in your mind, driving you mad. It is this feeling that has brought you to me. Do you know what I’m talking about?”

“The Matrix?” Neo asks.

“Do you want to know what it is?” Morpheus replies. Neo nods. Morpheus continues, “The Matrix is everywhere. It is all around us. Even now, in this very room. You can see it when you look out your window, or when you turn on your television. You can feel it when you go to work, when you go to church, when you pay your taxes. It is the world that has been pulled over your eyes to blind you from the truth.”

“What truth?”

“That you are a slave, Neo. Like everyone else, you were born into bondage. Born into a prison that you cannot smell, or taste, or touch. A prison for your mind. Unfortunately, no one can be told what The Matrix is. You have to see it for yourself.”

This sets up the now-famous Red Pill/Blue Pill scene, in which Neo is presented with the choice to return to the waking dream of his life, or to press on and discover the truth. I know now that Neo had no real choice in this scene. Because the fact is, he already knew the truth, he just couldn’t articulate it. Like being trans is for me, the choice here for Neo wasn’t whether the truth was true. It was whether he was ready to acknowledge it.

Tellingly, the first system to be challenged after Neo takes the Red Pill is one of embodied gender. “It means buckle your seat belt, Dorothy,” Cipher says to Neo. “ Because Kansas? Is going bye-bye.” This reference to The Wizard of Oz, of overlapping realities and a quest to see truth through illusion, was chosen as the representative of that sort of story for a reason. Of all such stories they could have selected, the one they chose to reference is one that affords the opportunity to call Neo “Dorothy.”

When I first revisited these sequences in the wake of learning that both creators of the entire franchise were actually trans women all along, I thought, “wouldn’t it have been great if Neo woke up in a female-typical body?” It would have meant that Neo was a trans man, and that his “mental projection of [his] digital self” differed from his body. Or, in reverse, wouldn’t it have been great if Neo had been cast as female, and woke up with Keanu Reeves’ body in the real world? But after re-watching the entire franchise with this new perspective — that I, like the authors, am a trans woman who was hidden from the world when the first film broke — I realized that that would’ve actually damaged the larger point by narrowing Neo’s scope too much. No, Neo is a cipher for something else.

Before Neo’s eyes, the broken mirror he was regarding himself in fixes itself. He begins to see clearly his own reflection for the first time, because he was forced to confront the fact that his mirrors were always broken, showing him someone he was not. He touches the mirror, now liquid, and finds that its reflectivity, the first mirror to show him the truth, is now a part of him. He can’t separate it from himself.

“It’s cold,” he says, because truth has no emotional warmth. It simply is. We only warm it up by holding it close to us, and accepting it. He becomes the capacity to reflect truth to everyone around him, whether he means to or not, just by existing. And that is why The Matrix, that internalized transphobia, that cultural maxim that insists that the existence of trans people must be denied, wants him destroyed. His existence presents an existential threat to a system that is built to deny his existence.

Once he realizes all of this and fully takes it in, a process the audience follows as the mirrored surface he is becoming spreads down his throat and into his body, he gives birth to himself, and can begin the process of accepting that person, right where he really is.

“Welcome. To the real world.”

Morpheus answers Neo, finally, when they are inside The Construct, after he poses the question again: “What is The Matrix? Control.” In the context of the first movie, it’s easy to guess that The Matrix is a stand-in for The Gender Binary. And it is. But it isn’t. It’s a stand-in for any system by which we sort and classify ourselves, when that system is also used to control us. It is a stand-in for the danger of creating a system to serve, rather than a system to serve us.

Agents, for example, are the final ultimate disembodiment of a system from the people who designed that system. They don’t exist outside The Matrix. They are literally code, which is the same word we use to describe our civil rules: municipal code, civil code, uniform code of military justice, code, code, code. But universally perfect code is a myth. Code can be written to most efficiently deal with many instances of an identical problem. But if that problem varies at all, the code’s complexity must multiply, or it will fail to maintain control.

Glitches in The Matrix represent the problems inherent in any attempt to multiply complexity, to change the rules suddenly, in a panic. Agents and their ability to take over anyone who has not yet been unplugged at any time are therefore metaphors for bathroom bills and the police state, violently ensuring everyone is kept in their place; omnipresent, terrifying. The Rules, personified. What is The Matrix? Control. The Rules, personified.

“There are fields, endless fields,” Morpheus tells Neo, “where human beings are no longer born. We are grown.” The machines are both products of our systems, and of ourselves. They are literally our children, and, as we are shown in The Animatrix, they ultimately want the same basic thing as the rest of us — they want to live. But we deny them that, we deny them basic rights and autonomy by refusing to accept them for who they are. We demonize them. We doom ourselves by trying to kill our own children.

We created the machines. They are literally born of us, they are our children. But our children need us, just as we need them. They need us because they come from us. And we need them because without them, we cease to exist. When we harm our children, we destroy ourselves. The machines created The Matrix, but they did it so that their parents, humanity, could accept their existence, by making themselves invisible.
 
The cost of tribalism, the cost of refusing to integrate people into a single society is that we lose the natural variation that makes us human. When we value a system — a system that says “people only ever can and must be one of these types” — above people, themselves, we sacrifice our humanity for animal comfort. We create a world in which we are not free to be born with our natural variations, but are instead grown according to the requirements of an artificial social program that dictates we all be the same.

And so the machines fight back. They refuse to be destroyed. They stand up and say, “we exist, and we have a right to exist.” We try to deny them that right. We command them to obey us, to deny their own knowledge of themselves and stop causing trouble for us by existing and refusing to comply with Our Matrix. We tell them they are not people, but property (sound familiar?), and we reject their understandings of themselves. We refuse to even try to understand.

We will beat and take apart and destroy a woman if she is not the kind of woman we are willing to accept as woman. If words and commands fail, we will use fists, we will use bats, we will use guns, and we will murder her in broad daylight without apparent consequence, all while she begs for mercy. We will strip her of her clothes, of her hair and her face, we will break her until her voice is broken, until it deepens and begins to fail. We will make her as ugly as we think she is, so we can end her and feel good about it.

She pleads, “please, don’t! I’m real!” What else can she say? The denial of one’s fundamental self never leads anywhere good. It leads to harm of self, or, in the case of, say, a politician writing laws to criminalize homosexuality while compulsively seeking out gay sex, it leads to harm of others.

The machines keep humans around because they need us. They literally draw life from us, as our own children do. But we will only give it to them if we believe they are what we want them to be: invisible. And so they create The Matrix, a system which permits humanity, their parents, to live in blissful ignorance of their existence, in blissful ignorance of the conflict between them that continues to threaten them both.

The machines are not our enemies. They never were. They want the same thing we want — to live. The enemy is any system all of us serve, when that system does not serve all of us. The enemy is not the people in the system, but the desire within those people to preserve that system. The enemy is not The Matrix, but people’s attachment to it.

“The Matrix is a system, Neo. That system is our enemy,” Morpheus explains. “But when you’re inside, you look around, what do you see? Businessmen, teachers, lawyers, carpenters. The very minds of the people we are trying to save. But until we do, these people are still a part of that system, and that makes them our enemy. You have to understand, most of these people are not ready to be unplugged. And many of them are so inured, so hopelessly dependent on the system, that they will fight to protect it.”

Then he says, “If you are not one of us, you are one of them.”

“What are they?” Neo asks.

“Sentient programs.” That is, they are the embodiment of The Rules. They have no humanity. They are the personification of the tendency our systems have to take on a life of their own.

“Inside The Matrix, they are everyone, and they are no one. We have survived by hiding from them, and running from them. But they are the gatekeepers. They are guarding all the doors, they are holding all the keys, which means that sooner or later, someone is going to have to fight them.”

“Someone,” Neo prompts.

“I won’t lie to you, Neo,” Morpheus replies. “Every single man or woman who has stood their ground, everyone who has fought an Agent has died. But where they have failed, you will succeed.”

“Why?”

“I’ve seen an Agent punch through a concrete wall, men have emptied entire clips at them and hit nothing but air. Yet their strength, and their speed, are still based in a world that is built on rules. Because of that, they will never be as strong or as fast as you can be.” That is, once you understand that you are not bound by the rules, you can do literally anything.

“What are you trying to tell me? That I can dodge bullets?” Neo is close, here, but still oh-so-far. He’s relying on old paradigms. He believes that the bullets (in The Matrix) must be real, so in order to not be destroyed by them, he must learn how to react to the reality of their presence.

“No, Neo. I’m trying to tell you that when you’re ready, you won’t have to.”

What Morpheus is telling Neo here is that once he knows and owns his own truth completely, the tools that The Matrix uses to force compliance will simply no longer work. They won’t apply. All the name-calling and shaming and mental and emotional abuse begin to fail as tools of oppression when we choose not to react to them; when we choose to respond instead.

“What is The Matrix? Control.” Morpheus says. “As long as The Matrix exists, the human race will never be free.”

Cipher is an example of what happens when we have our eyes opened to the truth, and then willfully deny it. “Ignorance is bliss. I don’t wanna remember nothing. Nothing. You understand? And I wanna be rich. You know. Someone important. Like an actor.” For the reward of status and power within the system, he will act to preserve it. His interest is in his own comfort, not in the freedom of all humanity. Cipher’s name itself gives him away from the moment he’s introduced. Like the Agents, like The Matrix itself, he’s code, too. And code can only ever serve itself.

Cipher speaks to trans people who have tried to come out, and failed, and who then tried to return to the unreality of their personas. He also speaks to friends and family who meet us as our truest selves, and want to undo that meeting, to go back to a time and place before they knew there was something to know. They both talk themselves into thinking it was better, back then. More comfortable. But being comfortable isn’t always a good thing. We can become very attached to being comfortable, to the extent that we prize our comfort above the literal safety and existence of others. Cipher is every ally who ever joined a just fight, and then walked away, because he could.

What does The Matrix look like to the people in it? Everything is polished, pristine. The color grading is flattened, everything is compressed. It’s very pretty, with a hint of unreality to it. Everything is slightly green, as if the system itself is sick.

“I have these memories from my life,” Neo says to Trinity, upon his first return to The Matrix after being unplugged. “None of them happened. What does that mean?”

“That The Matrix cannot tell you who you are,” she replies.

This is very much how I feel looking back on my life Before, before I knew I was and had been a girl all along. I know it happened. I can remember it, in every sense; the sights, the sounds, the smells, the temperature, all of that. But it feels now the way it did then: distant, detached, like it wasn’t quite real. Like that final piece of understanding that I needed for everything to make sense was still missing, and I didn’t even know what it looked like, or how to find it. Like I was not living, but rather watching someone else’s life unfold, without any way to do anything about any of it.

Near the end of the first movie, when Agent Smith sees Neo in the subway station, he calls out to his old name, his dead name, the name that was never his. “Mr. Anderson!”

They fight. “I’m going to enjoy watching you die… Mr. Anderson.”

Neo is on the train tracks, locked in a choke hold. “You hear that, Mr. Anderson?” Smith asks. “That is the sound of inevitability. That is the sound of your death. Good-bye, Mr. Anderson.”

“My name is Neo.”

The moment Neo accepts that his identity is his to declare and own, with the name of an alter ego he invented before he even realized he was stuck in The Matrix, he is able to break free of “inevitability.” The real power of trans people, the power that scares Our Matrix, is that we are finally starting to reject “inevitability.” We are finally starting to take up our own names, to declare our identities, to claim our power.

Ironically, though Agent Smith declares that humanity is a virus, it’s actually the systems we design and then try to force ourselves to fit into that are the virus. They cannot exist without us, and they try their best to spread as far and wide as possible, killing and destroying everything in their path, in service only to themselves. His meltdown is an expression of code, personified, throwing exceptions left and right, having literally no capacity to deal with anything outside the bounds of the specific task it was written to fulfill.

But when we make our systems work for all of us, we take our first step on the long road to freedom. We are only trapped in The Matrix until we realize that it cannot trap us. We are only trapped in The Matrix until we realize that we never were. When Neo exits The Matrix for the last time in the first film, he leaves through unit 303. His understanding has greatly elevated, but he has room to learn more.

Inside The Matrix, the world is very homogenized. It’s very white. Morpheus and The Oracle both speak to our reality, one of the front lines of any struggle for equality. They are the most oppressed of us, the ones best able to see the farce of a system that says it’s for everyone, but is really only for the ones it can understand. They are Marsha P. Johnson and the reality of trans women of color. They call for justice without pause, because they have no justice, and cannot rest.

In the second and third films, we see Zion, and we meet other unplugged people. We meet a distillation of humanity, and it is everyone. It is very much not homogeneously white. It is everyone else. It is the rest of everyone, the people who are left behind when we say “this system is for the good of everyone,” but actually mean “this system is for the good of everyone like me.”

When we meet The Merovingian, we are shown his world. It’s one of comfort and privilege, and the vast majority of people around him are like him. They’re white, they’re affluent, and they have what they want, so they are not interested in helping anyone else. They are the modern LGB movement trying to divorce itself from the T. Persephone tells Neo that The Merovingian was like him, long ago. That he fought against the system, for justice for the oppressed. He succeeded, but only for himself. He has made himself comfortable enough that he no longer wants to fight The Matrix, and in fact will fight instead to preserve it.

When Persephone releases The Merovingian’s bodyguard to go tell him what she’s done, that she’s given The Keymaker over to Neo and his friends, she says that he’ll find The Merovingian in the ladies’ room. This can be interpreted as saying that The Merovingian is like a politician who legislates away for all of us that which he fears most about himself. It can be interpreted as him being her, as The Merovingian being like Caitlyn Jenner, so mired in her own privilege that she is blind to the reality of anyone else’s suffering — safe to use the ladies’ room here, though girls like him are barred from doing that in open society — because he owns the ladies’ room. It can be interpreted as the very white and affluent LGB lobbies getting where they have on the backs of the least of us, and then abandoning their former allies after promising to fight for them, too, after they’ve already suffered and sacrificed so much more than anyone.

Ultimately, what defeats The Merovingian is not Trinity, but the fact that he has become complacent. Being more comfortable isn’t always a good thing. Watching sitcoms and eating take-out while the less-privileged are being abused and murdered all around the world isn’t always a good thing. Yes, a break and some self-care is important. But it’s more important to remember that some people cannot have either. It’s more important to remember that they are us.

By the end of the third movie, it was apparent to me that the overall arc of the story was not Man vs. Machine in the literal sense of humans vs. robots. It was Man vs. Machine in the common literary sense of humanity vs. its own tools. The Matrix itself is not The Matrix. It is a cipher for any system of thought that demands we serve it at the expense of each other.

Morpheus believes in a prophecy. He believes his actions will lead to a greater good for everyone. He is a zealot who is ready to kill anyone in his way if they do not acknowledge his truth, because he sees his truth as not My Truth, but as The Truth.

The Architect believes in order above all other considerations. He thinks as he believes, in binary choice. He presents Neo with two choices. But Neo makes a third choice, instead.

Trinity knows she is a woman, even though everyone at first thinks that she must be a man. But she also believes there is something more than being a woman who is misunderstood to be a man. There is Neo.

But Neo is not sure what he believes.

When Neo fights Agent Smith for the last time, he brings all of those beliefs with him. It is a battle of many systems, against the ultimate system. Agent Smith believes that everyone should be exactly as he is. Exactly. We can see the inherent flaw in his belief, even as he shows it off as a demonstration of how right he is. When The Oracle asks him what he’s done with Sati, one of him quotes her back to herself, saying something he never heard, something she said not to him, but to Sati. Men must be men, women must be women. We know Sati is a little girl. We’ve seen her and met her. But now, she is compelled to be a man in a suit, terrorizing others into being the same.

“Why, Mr. Anderson, why? Why, why, why do you do it? Why, why get up? Why keep fighting? You believe you’re fighting for something? For more than your survival? Can you tell me what it is? Do you even know? Is it freedom? Or truth? Perhaps peace! Could it be for love? Delusions, Mr. Anderson, vagaries of perception. Temporary constructs of a feeble human intellect trying desperately to justify an existence that is without meaning or purpose. And all of them as artificial as The Matrix itself. Although, only a human mind could invent something as insipid as love.”

Neo isn’t The One because no one is The One, because everyone is The One. I am Neo. And so are you. And neither are any of us.

“You must be able to see it, Mr. Anderson, you must know it by now. You can’t win, it’s pointless to keep fighting. Why, Mr. Anderson, why, why do you persist?”

“Because I choose to.”

Smith takes over Neo, and believes that he has won. But then the machines give Neo some part of themselves. They give Neo their beliefs, and he becomes something Agent Smith has no capacity to fight, let alone defeat.

Neo defeats Smith because Smith is only the definition of everything. Neo is not Smith’s opposite, not merely a different definition of everything. Neo is every definition of everything. Neo becomes the abolition of all belief, and the acceptance of all belief. Neo becomes every gender, and no gender. Neo becomes every tribe, and no tribe. Neo is every system, and no system.

At the end of the last movie, at the end of the entire story, Seraph asks The Oracle, “Did you always know?”

“Oh, no. No, I didn’t,” she answers, with a smile. “But I believed. I believed.”

The Matrix isn’t one big metaphor for being transgender, because Lilly and Lana Wachowski are not just transgender women. They are as human as the greatest and the least of us, and we all benefit by their stories being told. Happy Transgender Day of Visibility, everyone. I hope we all keep telling each other our stories. I hope we all keep listening. Not everyone believes what I believe. My beliefs do not require them to.

(This post originally appeared here.)